Start a community

How to start an online community: a practical 7-step plan

A new community needs one clear reason for members to come back each week and a small founding group to test it with in the first month.

Lockers logoBy Ryan Scott, founder of LockersUpdated August 28, 20267 min read

A small group sharing a meal around a table with open booksFour adults around a coffee shop table with open BiblesA member count card with an avatar stack

1. Define why someone would return

A card with member comments

Write one sentence that names the member, the progress they want, and the recurring reason to come back, which should be something the group does together that is harder to do alone. If the sentence only describes what you will post, it describes a content channel, which members can follow without talking to each other.

2. Choose the simplest model that fits

Decide whether the main value is conversation, structured learning, ongoing access, or a time-bound result. You can combine those later, but one of them should lead the first version.

  • Community: members learn mainly from conversation and each other.
  • Membership: people pay for continuing access, guidance, resources, or proximity.
  • Cohort: a group moves through a defined experience on a shared schedule.
  • Course with community: lessons provide the path and discussion helps people finish it.

3 to 5. Build only what the first month needs

A notifications card with three updates
  1. Pick one primary member action

    Choose the behavior that creates value: ask a question, share progress, attend a session, or complete a lesson. Put that action in the clearest place.

  2. Create three to five useful spaces

    Begin with announcements, introductions, the main work, and help. Empty categories make a new community look abandoned to the first members who arrive.

  3. Prepare the first two weeks of posts and events

    Prepare a welcome post, an orientation, two easy discussion prompts, one useful resource, and the first live or shared moment before invitations go out.

A small group community feed with a backyard dinner post and a full right rail

6 and 7. Invite a small founding group and learn from what they do

Invite people individually and tell them why their participation matters. Ten members who post and reply give you enough activity to see which prompts and spaces work.

A group passing dishes down a long backyard table at dusk

For the first 30 days, watch what members do without reminders, which questions repeat, and which parts of the structure nobody uses. Keep the prompts and spaces that help members make progress, and rename, merge or remove the ones nobody uses.

  • Ask every founding member what would make the space worth revisiting next week.
  • Respond quickly enough that early participation feels consequential.
  • End the month with one visible improvement based on member behavior.